Something interesting about Milwaukee is that Halloween is tightly under government wraps. For example, trick-or-treating doesn't happen on Halloween night, but it is scheduled at different times for each neighborhood on the days leading up to Halloween. (So our neighborhood's time was on Saturday night from 6:30-8:30). You have to register with the city to trick-or-treat, and you have to pay dues. Then the city hands you buckets of candy to give out. They give you a sign to put on your door that shows that you've paid your dues and that you're a registered candy-hander-outer. They give you the bag to use for trick-or-treating. They give you a sheet of Halloween rules.
PROS to socialized Halloween:
1) The safety. Police are stationed at the street corners for whatever neighborhood is scheduled to trick or treat. Roads are closed to all cars.
2) The neighborhood spirit. Being so organized makes Halloween a BIG DEAL! Blocks went all out in competitions of who could decorate the best for Halloween. I've never seen such amazing, intense Halloween spirit! Since trick-or-treating was scheduled for just 2 hours, everyone in our neighborhood sat on their porch steps for the 2 hours to hand out candy. We didn't ring any doorbells or go into any homes-- we just walked from house to house and talked with all the neighbors.
3) The candy. You're not worried about the candy you're given, since it's fresh, new, clean and from the government!
CONS to socialized Halloween:
1) The candy. You don't get very much name-brand candy or great big candy bars. You can't hit up certain blocks who you know "give out the best stuff." Since the city paid for all of the candy for all of the trick-or-treaters in Milwaukee (that's a LOT OF CANDY), you get the cheap, small stuff. It also stifles creativity when you're assigned with what to give out.
2) The organization. If you weren't on top of things and forgot to register to trick-or-treat, too bad.
3) The police. It makes you nervous to have police and security guards everywhere while you trick or treat.
Anyway, there are some great benefits to having the government control Halloween, as well as some definite drawbacks. Which is better: people-controlled Halloween, or government-controlled Halloween? With the presidential election looming, and one candidate saying we need more government control over our lives and the other saying we need less government control over our lives, it was interesting to experience a highly government-controlled Halloween. And now, John and I are basing our vote next Tuesday on our experience at Halloween! (Okay, not really, but it did give us some food for thought.)
